No Promise of a Rose Garden

Since the Marine Corps’ earliest years, it has been the duty of senior noncommissioned officers to drill, drill, inspect, and drill again the young men who profess a desire to become a United States Marine. In the days of sail, the arts and sciences of Marine Corps training included instruction about history and traditions, discipline, marksmanship, sword drill, close order drill, physical fitness training, the care and cleaning of uniforms, equipment, and small arms, service at sea, and the fundamentals of naval artillery. There was then, in the olden days, as there is now, much to learn about serving as a Marine — but there is not much time to learn it. So, recruit training is as relentless as it is rigorous. Only the best-qualified recruit is allowed to graduate into that sea of faces we sometimes call the ranks of a Marine Brigade.

To young recruits, seasoned NCOs represent the “old Corps.” Of course, the expression “old corps” is somewhat of an old saw — and to some Marines, “old corps” was last year.  Marine NCOs are men who possess corporate knowledge of how the Marine Corps works — the often complex workings of the operating forces on land and at sea.  The process of training recruits has changed over the years, of course, but the well-established tradition does continue. In time, some of these young recruits will become Drill Instructors themselves.[1] Of course, for that to happen, a Marine has to have the stuffing to remain in the Corps long enough to become a seasoned NCO. Not everyone has staying power — and the mission becomes even more, demanding with seniority. The Marine Corps has never been an organization for lightweights.

In the days before recruit depots, most recruit training occurred at designated Navy Yards in Philadelphia, Brooklyn, or at the Marine Barracks on Eighth & I Streets — just down the street from the Washington Navy Yard. Back then, all training was localized. The quality of the training received had everything to do with the quality of the NCO trainer, and even though the Marine Corps demanded formal training for recruits since around 1804, there was no money for textbooks or other written materials.  Additionally, since Congress placed a ceiling on enlisted strength levels and made no allowance for drill instructors, trainers had to come from locally available personnel. 

Marine Corps staffing levels were such that the Corps could ill-afford to squander what they had available for their assigned mission. The Marine Corps has never had “an abundance” of NCOs suitable for service as drill instructors. But before 1900, recruit training fell upon the shoulders of NCOs assigned D.I. duty. For the most part.

In 1860, the United States began to prepare for a war between the states. Everyone knew that war was likely. Some people even looked forward to war. Washington politicians had tried diplomacy since 1820 and failed — maybe it was simply time to “get on with it.”

These preparations included recruiting additional men for service in the Army, Navy, and Marine Corps. In July, youngsters began streaming into the Washington Navy Yard for recruit training in Washington. But in mid-July, the Army needed men to confront rebels forming at Manassas — so, trained or not, Marine NCOs at the Navy Yard mustered their recruits and marched them off to join the picnic.

The First Battle of Manassas was no picnic — even though several members of Congress packed picnic lunches and escorted their wives to watch the fun.

Those young Marines did have initiative, but they were of little use in the fight beyond carrying ammunition to support Army artillery units. In 1861, Marines were trained for service at sea, not on land. In 1861, amphibious warfare doctrine was still sixty years into the future.

In 1911, Major General Commandant William P. Biddle standardized recruit training for all Marines, coast-to-coast: drill, physical exercise, hand-to-hand combat, and intensive marksmanship training. Biddle established four recruit training depots: Philadelphia, Norfolk, Puget Sound, and Mare Island. The depots at Philadelphia and Puget Sound were closed. Four years later, in 1915, the Norfolk training depot was moved to its present location, Parris Island, South Carolina.

As the United States began moving toward its involvement in the European war, the number of recruits-in-training at any one time surged from 835 to 13,286. After “boot camp,” Marines went to Quantico, Virginia, for their pre-deployment (unit) training. There to greet them, undoubtedly, were the NCOs — most of whom had served in combat during U.S. interventions in the Caribbean and Central America. Once in France, Marine units underwent additional “land warfare” training.

Boot Camp is where the Marine Corps makes Marines — and has been for the past 111 years. The people who make these Marines are called Drill Instructors (DIs). When most civilians think of the Marines (which probably isn’t often), they probably think of a recruiting poster, such as the one on the right. DIs are the stuff of legends — among the most professional leaders in the Marine Corps. The primary candidate for Drill Instructor School are sergeants and staff sergeants. Anyone eligible to serve as a drill instructor can be directed to appear before a Drill Instructor Screening Board — but not every NCO can become a DI. The Screening Board only selects the most qualified NCO to attend Drill Instructor School. Why? Because it is the solemn duty of the DI to transition undisciplined civilians into United States Marines — there’s no room for error.

What makes these Marines among the best in the Corps? They have to be exceptional in their regular MOS, they have to meet height/weight criteria, they have to look sharp in their uniforms, they have to be among the Corps’ top sharpshooters, and they have to achieve a near-perfect physical fitness score. If they’re married Marines, they have to have a stable family life and be financially secure. To become a DI, they must be even-tempered, judicious, and informed decision-makers. There are no “crazies” walking around under DI covers. Marine DIs might appear unhinged to the recruit standing in front of them, but that DI anger is all part of a carefully cultivated act — an act they learn at DI School.

Today, the two major recruit training depots (MCRDs) are located at Parris Island, South Carolina, and San Diego, California. There are DI Schools at each location. The coursework is tough, the physical training relentless, and there are uniform inspections every single day. There is no such thing as an un-squared away Marine Corps Drill Instructor. If an applicant is selected for DI School at PISC, his DI duty assignment will also be at PISC — that is, if they graduate. Not everyone does.

For that reason, DI candidates aren’t permitted to take their families with them to the MCRD until after they’ve graduated and received their first DI assignment. The work of a DI is relentlessly difficult, but so too is the life of a DI’s wife. Rocky marriages don’t last a single tour of DI duty.

DI duty is demanding. Whatever Marine Corps training demands of its recruits, it demands five times that of its drill instructors. If the recruits are awakened at 0500, the DIs are up at 0400. Recruits are put to bed at 2200, but their DI is up past midnight. Recruits may look ratty by the end of the day, but their DI always looks poster-perfect. They change into fresh uniforms three or four times a day.

Each recruit platoon has between 60-80 recruits. Because these recruits demand their DI’s full attention 24 hours a day (times forever), DIs work in teams of three or four — generally as follows:

  • Each platoon will have two or three Junior Drill Instructors (J.D.I.’s). These NCOs instruct in the training and discipline of troops; make sure that recruits are up on time, march to chow at the right time, march to medical and dental periods on time, march to training sessions on time, get showered, and hit the rack on time. J.D.I.’s also make sure their recruits write home to the folks regularly.
  • The Senior Drill Instructor (S.D.I.) is responsible for the platoon and the J.D.I.’s. The senior can be just as terrifying as the others but is also considered the “adult in the room.” If something goes wrong (no matter what) — it’s the SDI’s fault. It can be career-ending if something goes wrong (no matter what).

What most people don’t realize is that officer candidates have DIs too. They aren’t called DIs, but most have completed a successful tour of DI duty. At Navy and Marine Corps officer candidate schools, D.I.’s are called Sergeants Instructors.

NCOs have much to say about who may graduate and receive a Navy and Marine Corps commission.  This situation may seem strange — but one of an NCOs most important responsibilities is to help train, assist, and advise Navy and Marine Corps officers.  This relationship between officers and NCOs is a long-held tradition that lasts for an entire career.  Even general officers and admirals have senior enlisted advisors. Competent officers listen carefully to what their NCOs have to say. The not-so-bright officers will probably never make it past captain — which is not bad.

Marine Corps Drill Instructors take a solemn pledge:

“These recruits are entrusted to my care. I will train them to the best of my ability. I will develop them into smartly disciplined, physically fit, basically trained Marines, thoroughly indoctrinated in love of Corps and country. I will demand of them and demonstrate by my example the highest standards of personal conduct, morality, and professional skill.”

How Important is Boot Camp?

Twenty-four hundred Marines were killed or wounded on the first day of Operation Detachment. Historian J. A. Colon recently asked, “Was the Marine Corps’ success at Iwo Jima a matter of leadership, bravado, or fundamental training? What prompted the Marines of the 3rd, 4th, and 5th Marine Divisions to succeed in a ruthless battle lasting 36 excruciating days? In this study, Colon examined the efficiency of recruit training (boot camp), replacement training, and unit training as it related to the success of the Iwo Jima campaign, noting in that study that one-quarter of all Medals of Honor awarded to Marines during World War II were earned on Iwo Jima.

Colon deduced that boot camp training proved far more essential than pre-operation or replacement training, a conclusion reached not through historiographical studies but through the personal testimonies of the Marines who fought that dreadful battle. Where the pre-operational training was incomplete, lacking realism, and the SWAG of operational planners, Marines retained their knowledge of boot camp training from the start of the operation to its conclusion. Boot camp imbued Marines with their sense of duty, gave them confidence in their weapons, and brought them to the point where they could endure the physical and mental stresses of bloody combat. What allowed the Marines to succeed at Iwo Jima, indeed, every Pacific combat operation was their self-discipline, self-confidence, and the esprit de corps instilled in them by their Marine Corps Drill Instructor.

To clarify — talk to anyone who has successfully served in the Marine Corps, and they will assure you that their boot camp training has remained with them all the days of their lives since graduation.

Drill Instructors, Platoon 224 Company E, 2ndBn RTR MCRD PISC

Sergeant J. S. Schweingruber

Sergeant R. S. Winston

Sergeant S. M. Nikolopoulos

Corporal J. D. Baker

Except for (Sergeant Major) Nikolopoulos, it’s been 60 years since I’ve seen these men. They were my drill instructors. That’s how significant Marine Corps Recruit Training is.


[1] The only service of the U.S. Armed Forces to use the term “drill instructor” is the U.S. Marine Corps.  In both the Navy, and Marine Corps, Marine Corps Drill Instructors train officer candidates, while Recruit Division Commanders (R.D.C.’s) train Navy enlisted personnel.  Air Force recruits are trained by Military Training Instructors(M.T.I.s).  In the Army, they are called drill sergeants.

[2] The drill instructor appearing in this 1968 recruiting poster is Sergeant Charles Taliano, USMC (Deceased) (1945-2010).  He was a native of Cleveland, Ohio.  He left the Marine Corps in 1968 to work in the publishing industry.  He retired in 1999 and relocated to Beaufort, South Carolina in 2001.  There, he served as the manager of the MCRD PISC gift shop.  He was buried at the Beaufort National Cemetery. 

Published by


Retired Marine, historian, writer.

7 thoughts on “No Promise of a Rose Garden”

  1. Years ago, a tale circulated around the Corps about the annual “drive” for candidates for Drill Instructor duty. Detailing qualified candidates to attend DI School and serve successfully in this “special duty assignment” is an involved process. It begins when HQMC staffing experts identify the names of certain Marines who may “have what it takes” to serve in this vital assignment successfully.

    Once HQMC identifies its initial list of candidates, it is up to unit commanders to validate the Marine’s qualification. A suitable candidate must look the part of a Marine Corps drill instructor — that “no nonsense” look of an experienced NCO. They must meet a minimum intelligence score, be in top physical shape, and be qualified with service weapons. But there’s more. Successful candidates must be financially steady, not have a drinking problem, and have a stable relationship if they’re married.

    Once unit commanders certify that candidates meet the essential criteria, identified Marines will report to the nearest Marine Corps Recruit Depot for further evaluation. They may take a physical fitness test and appear before a board of NCOs and officers to answer questions. They have to be evaluated psychologically.

    The truth is that serving as a DI is hard work and never stops. A DI is up at 0300, often works late into the night, and works weekends and holidays. It’s a tough régime on the Marine, and it’s hard on the family, too. The DI may not be home for wedding anniversaries or the children’s birthdays. These are not little things. Despite the screening for such things as stable marriages, etc., DIs experience high divorce rates. It’s a tough life for three or more years — and no surprise that not every NCO wants to serve as a Drill Instructor.

    Still, as with most things in the Corps, Marines don’t get to pick and choose their duty assignments. If DI candidates pass the screening, they will likely report to DI School for further training, whether they like it or not. Unless — they can find some way of demonstrating that they aren’t what the Marine Corps wants under a campaign cover.

    With twelve years in service, one staff sergeant DI candidate knew how things work in the Corps. He didn’t want to be a DI … he wanted to stay in his preferred occupational field: aircraft maintenance. It made no sense to him that after spending thousands of dollars training him to maintain expensive airplanes, HQMC would send him away to do something other than fixing high-performance aircraft. But orders are orders, and he appeared before the DI Screening Course at MCRD San Diego, as directed.

    The individual who performs the psychological assessment is a Navy doctor. Navy doctors don’t understand much about life in the Marine Corps, but it seemed to this particular doctor that hardly anyone wanted to serve as a Marine Corps drill instructor. He’d been sitting at his desk all day long, listening to Marines argue about how they weren’t psychologically qualified to serve as a DI. By 1700 in the afternoon, the doctor was tired and ready to quit for the day. Luckily, there was only one candidate left to interview.

    It happened to be the air winger — who also didn’t want to become a DI. The NCO knocked on the doctor’s office door when told he was next — and he entered when invited. “Sit down,” said the doctor. The Marine sat down. The doctor wiped his eyes with his dominant hand and said, somewhat tiredly, “Okay, gunny … let’s cut to the chase here. How many recruits can you get inside a dumpster?”

    It was a dream come true. The DI candidate was a mechanic. He knew how to solve mechanical problems. Without skipping a beat, he replied, “That depends on how small the pieces are, sir.”

    Liked by 3 people

  2. I can’t really comment all years later for the Army and it has probably changed. Of course the qualifications for the USMC are different than the Army as every Marine is foremost a rifleman.
    First is the ‘Drill Sargent’ known as a “Drill Sargent” as such, and not as a DI. The stock answer coming from a Drill Sargent, to a recruit daring to call a Drill Sargent a DI would in result of said recruit receiving extra PT and the admonition that a DI is a dead Marine (not my admonition).
    The ranking system in the Army is different. The E4 rank being a Spec 4 (No stripes, Specialist patch), except for the Artillery MOS where they become a Corporal if they hold a NCO slot and attend the NCO academy/school (2 stripes up).
    Drill Sergent’s can only come from those in combat arms primary MOSs, i.e. Infantry Artillery or Armor (I was Artillery). For instance, if you had a primary MOS of a cook, you could not attend the school or become a Drill Sergent.
    I was brevetted to the rank to Sergent from Spec4 and remained a Sergent through my separation from active duty (I was unwilling to re-up for 6 years).

    Liked by 2 people

    1. There is a sign outside the MCRD Parris Island that reads, “The Marine Corps’ two most important missions are making Marines and winning battles.” I think it was a quotation from one of our former Commandants.

      Liked by 3 people

    2. There is whole different mindset between a Marine and an Army infantryman. Being a Marine is a vocation, being in the Army is just a job (at least for most).

      Liked by 2 people

  3. Outstanding piece, Mustang, Sir! Enjoyed it! Staff Sgt. Dietz and I looked quite a bit a like with our heads shaved. He terrorized me. Someday I’ll tell the tale, if you’d like. Staff Sgt. Langhorn was the Senior. He was so dark, all you saw was his eyes scanning the room…Sgt. Smith looked like “Chesty” and couldn’t keep from causing us to laugh which always resulted in the sand pit. And Sgt. Beatty was the stuff of nightmares, evil little man with a raspy voice, was rumored to have lost a stripe for beating a recruit and was the only one who struck us, (but never with his body, he preferred the M16A1 front site at the position of present arms. Many of us had nose and facial scars from inadvertently striking ourselves with the front site).
    In my fire service career, I was and am known for my Marineness and it has often resulted in flak coming down range…, I was asked if I could put a little more military in our fire academy. I said I would try but in truth, I had no idea if I could pull it off, after all…it had been twenty years…I came around the end file of the front rank. Each fire recruit wearing their dress shirt and helmet. I took one look down the rank looking for alignment, spotted Recruit Flanders with his helmet tipped back like “howdy doody” and I lost it! Pitch perfect, deadpan, “Oh no! Oh no! You!!!! Yes, Yooouuu!!! Who do you think you are, f*&%$! Barney Fife? I’ve got your number Flanders!!!” I was off and running. The chief’s eyes were popping out and I figured I was going to be fired, but once out, the demon took over. Flat voiced, sarcastic, bordering acidic, I had no idea, no clue that that dwelled in me. It was only a shadow of what I had been exposed to, I was just shocked out how incredibly natural it was. It was all an act, yet it flowed… The chief took off to go protect my job with the big boss. It was like a whole other side of me I didn’t know existed. Two recruits quit within the first weekend and another one was crying to his parents that he wanted to leave (that parent later thanked me).
    Scary what the Corps instilled and has no way to remove or deactivate. I had to learn to control it. The recruits loved it…The difference was I was making firefighters and public servants. So everything I did and said was geared to communicate duty, service, and my belief in their ability to complete the task. Never negative or derogatory (except in jest) and always building up. It was very effective but made other officers negative towards me (the non-vet crowd). That’s enough, …don’t want to hog your great write-up!

    –Semper Fi!!

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s